29 April 2006

Ta Prohm

















Incredible and Indescribable!

And this is my tiny Sri Lankan friend from office.

Angkor Wat II





Angkor Wat Palatial Complex I










Temple Bayon II











At Bayon's entrance religious women monks greet you/peddle you for money and to make an offering to Buddha. From my understanding the religion in Cambodia is a fusion of Hinduism and Buddhism, justufying Buddha's existence by claiming he is a reincarnation of Vishnu. In all the temples and in Angkor Wat palatial complex, there are incredibly complicated etched epics along all the walls. Emerging from the temple sites, there are usually market stalls with vendors selling every imaginable souvenir. The most beautiful silk scarves and silk handbags truly mark Cambodia;s survival in the textile industry, after the phase-out of quota system. From the International Labour Organisation, Cambodia is seen to have secured their markets in EU by promoting its high labor standards within its textile sector; but I'm always skeptical at this claim. And I defnly wish I had time to visit a silk farm and seen the extraction of silk from worms.

One of the most awestriking aspects about Cambodia is that about 70-80% of the country is under 21 years old, and only 20% of young girls finish primary school education. So when you see people over 40 you really notice. Does this mean that the textile industry is run by teenagers? How does that fit into ILO labor standards? There are many young marriages, with teenagers caring for their young children. It is really an interesting story in development that this country is built by such young people, all on motorbikes! Most young people speak English/French as well as Khmer. So I heard several stories from teenage shopkeepers that their parents were killed under the Khmer Rouge, and that they are bringing up their siblings. During the early morning when walking around some of the temples, young children beg tourists for US dollars while their older siblings run the market stalls and roadside cafes. In the late afternoon, children home from school spend their playtime selling trinkets to foreigners, (practicing their economics, geography and multiple languages). I;m not sure what to make of it all, given that I was there for such a short time, but the young people seem so resilient, charasmatic, charming, persistent, and the best salespeople I;ve ever seen in action!

Temple Bayon in Siem Riep












Last month we held a regional orientation on trade-related issues and porjections of the Doha Development Round on meeting human development goals. Participants from all over Asia and Pacific region gathered in Siem Riep, and in the early mornings before the programme started I was able to visit some of the surrounding temples, including Bayon. Angkor Wat, the ancient Siamese capital had been abandoned when Thailand invaded it around 12th century. Malaria outbreaks and the high cost of running the massive city contributed to rulers' languid approach when invaders took over. For several centuries the city was left in ruins, for the rainforest to devour it. In 1920s a French traveller came across the intricately carved faces of Bayon, peering out eerily behind the jungle's curtains.

23 April 2006

Only the tiles of the floors were left

















































A brief trip south to Galle revealed on a very vivid, horrifying scale the impact of the tsunami on people living in the south and east of Sri Lanka. Colombo had relatively little damage and human loss, only there is a surge of displaced people and migrants who continually come to the large city in search of employment and their familial ties. But the trail of devastation accompanies your journey down to the southernmost tip of the country. Entire houses, shops, lives and livelihoods were swept away, with the shocking remnants of their concrete slab kitchen sinks and tiled floors still jutting out. Those people killed are generally buried in mass graves along the sea-facing road. Many of the former inhabitants moved in with their families, and despite official reports that most survivors are taken care of, people still live in donated tents, forage for food and stable income, and wait on their daily relief. Ironically, you see that many people used UNHCR tents to tarp over the damage in their homes.

It was difficult to walk around the tent cities, or to gawk at the destruction, or to treat this tragedy as a tourist attraction, so I can only speak from memory (an erroneous source in itself). And it is absolutely incomprehensible that one year plus some months later that little of the aid from governments in the region, the UN funds, and NGO assistance have gotten back to the survivors. These people survived 20 years of conflict, the 'Big Wave' and now face the challenges of international 'benevolence' and 'aid capitalism.' For sure, this humanitarian disaster received the largest amount of aid and international outreach in history, but the methods of distribution, monitoring funds, local consultation and ethics have been grotesque, imperial, shady to say the least.

For instance, it's a massive mistake to have handed over the billions of funds to a corrupt, warmongering government, who's already misspent monies, in part on military expenses (whoah - how familiar is this experience in the western hemisphere?). More fundamental are the inherent flaws of the international aid architecture, that do not take in the very particular circumstances within the country needing the relief. Namely, they do not take in the complexities of aid in post-conflict recovery or on using the established networks of organisations already working in the country/region. Instead, alot of organisations inexperienced in Sri Lanka flooded the affected areas with their well-meanings and good intentions, but contributed to chaos and poor decisions. Many foreign volunteers do not speak the language and treat survivors with paternalism rather than listening with compassion. According to Sri Lankan social scientist, Dr. Darini Rajasingham Senanayake, "Each one of their air tickets and per diems may have paid for the rebuilding of a couple of tsunami-devastated homes." It does more good to employ/mobilise the underemployed university graduates, who may have a more sound grasp on the local situation, to carry out the relief work. Some of the negative reprecussions from the uncoordinated or ill-advised programmes can be seen as a disjuncture between state control of immediate international funds and its own agenda, and community knowledge and development initiatives.

One of the most gruesome outcomes from lack of coordination, includes how the looming possibility of returning to conflict, created a demand for LTTE recruits. Many children orphaned by the tsunami since have been recruited as child soldiers and trafficked into sex work to cater to the foreign paedophiles. In addition, areas that cater more to business and tourism received more immediate attention and relief in order to quickly resume one of the main service industries on the island. Approximately 55,000 temporary houses have been built in southern region but only one around Jaffna. Tamil people often face added, unjust hardships by the Government of Sri Lanka, who penalise survivors for being in the 'wrong' part of the country, not on the Singhalese side. Preventing relief agencies to come into the north and east by the LTTE, as well as the government's poor decisions not to focus on largely Tamil communities north, could exacerbate the teetering conflict. Moreover, while temporary housing is more available, permanent housing and strategies for long term recovery are still unfolding.

It is clear that the enormous funds pouring in internationally need to be held accountable to the survivors and distribution in Sri Lanka requires more effective monitoring. UN agencies have good transparency in terms of their funding expenditure, but bureacracy has tied up alot of the aid, instead of getting back to people (UN is angrily frowned upon here - best not to mention affiliation). As well, using aid to attain political ends exacerbates the conflict and hardships endured by the affected communities. How do we link established organisations working here to (larger, international) organisations that have the capabilities to expand project operations so that these juggernauts of relief and recovery can really manage sustained development?

In reference to article by:
Dr. Darini Rajasingham Senanayake."Humanitarian Assistance and Disaster Management: Lessons from Sri Lanka and India" ASEAN Roundtable 2005: The Asian Tsunami: Implications for Regional Development and Security, Institute of Southeast Asia Studies, Singapore